Ki2.6 Perceptions of Flood Risk
| Back |    
  Students should consider the concept that different groups within a drainage basin perceive floods in various ways. Some perceptions may be positive whilst many will be negative. There will also be different perceptions according to the location within the basin, economic impacts, the needs of the group to respond to the flood, political impacts etc.  
     
  Flood Plain flood risk  
  Effects of flooding on people  
  Model of Flood Perception  
  Yorkshire flood survey http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/england/south_yorkshire/7453531.stm  
  Gloucestershire County Council Flood Response Strategy  
 
Group
Investigation
  mainly fieldwork  
     
     
     
     
     
     
     
     
     
  swiss research http://coolrisk.com/risk-flooding

The results were similar to findings in other risk perception studies; people at high risk tended to underestimate the risk while those at low risk tended to overestimate.

 
 

Research in Switzerland

A recent study (Siegrist and Gutscher, 2006) looked at people's perceptions of flood risk in Switzerland. The Swiss authorities also publish detailed maps showing the risks for different areas. The researchers asked people to give their own assessment of the flood risk in their area and these perceptions were compared to the experts' estimates. The results were similar to findings in other risk perception studies; people at high risk tended to underestimate the risk while those at low risk tended to overestimate. Most of them didn't know about the official flood-risk maps. Nevertheless, people in general agreed with the experts as to whether the flood risk was above or below average.

What's really interesting about the Swiss study is that they asked people about their preparedness for flooding. In particular, they asked whether people kept important documents in their cellars. They found that people's behaviour was much the same, whether or not they lived in a high-risk or a low-risk area. In other words, people still kept important stuff in their cellar even though they lived in a high-risk area... and they themselves recognised that they lived in a high-risk area!

http://www.rics.org/site/download_feed.aspx?fileID=2716&fileExtension=PDF survey of valuers about impact of flooding on house prices.

 

http://www.floodforum.org.uk/files/Maddi%20Bali.pdf flood forum survey GLOUCESTERSHIRE loads of details photos

http://www.cieh.org/uploadedFiles/Core/Membership/Regional_network/South_West_region/July_Floods_2007-Gloucester.pdf photos

 

 
 
  roles EA   LEA   utilities   emergency agencies hydrologists-research findings to LEA see eval link  
  http://www.floodforum.org.uk/files/Maddi%20Bali.pdf Gloucestershire LEA good photos - evaluation  
  EA  
  http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/england/south_yorkshire/7453531.stm Yorkshire flood survey  
  http://www.worcestershirepartnership.org.uk/cms/theme-groups/environment-group/state-of-the-env-report/soe-report/climate-change/properties-at-risk-flood-plain.aspx properties at risk - cost upton scheme
  valuers - on U/S word page  
  LA - planning permission  
  http://e-access.malvernhills.gov.uk/eaccess/showattach.asp?ID=293649 upton  
  http://www.environment-agency.gov.uk/static/documents/Research/09_chapter3_3_to_3.1_2050198.pdf p108 upton 2007